1. Apply an exception before the general rule
Read this original receiving notice from a fictional distribution center.
Receiving notice
For deliveries with an intact security seal, sign the delivery record, move the cartons to the storage area and send the record to the receiving office before the end of the shift.
If a security seal is broken, leave the delivery in the receiving area and contact the shift supervisor before signing any delivery record. Only the supervisor may authorize acceptance of a delivery with a broken seal.
A delivery arrives with a broken security seal. What should the receiving employee do next?
- A.Sign the record and send it to the office at the end of the shift.
- B.Move the cartons to storage, then contact the supervisor.
- C.Leave the delivery in receiving and contact the supervisor before signing.
- D.Sign the record if the cartons appear undamaged.
- E.Reject the delivery immediately without contacting anyone.
Show answer and explanation
C. Leave the delivery in receiving and contact the supervisor before signing.
- The broken seal triggers the second paragraph, so the normal sign-and-store sequence does not apply.
- That paragraph requires the delivery to remain in receiving and the supervisor to be contacted before any signature.
- The notice does not let the employee accept apparently undamaged cartons or require immediate rejection. Those answers invent a rule.
State the trigger first, then follow its instruction. An answer that follows only the general rule can be wrong.